Caldwell​のベストピッツェリア

Very good food, prompt service. A bit pricey, but what isn't these days?

We had a delicious Caesar Salad and then Killer Bee and Oscar the Grouch Pizzas which were fresh and incredibly delicious. Leave room for incredibly desserts!!! And there is an amazing Happy Hour with drink specials and amazingly priced treats!! Service and ambiance is friendly, neighborly and perfect!!

My daughter and I went for dinner before a show. Our server Dawson was excellent! He was personable, knowledgeable and helpful. We started with the breadsticks with Marinara sauce which was delicious. We both got the Wood Roasted Cod and for sides we shared the sweet potato & kale Au Gratin and the roasted broccoli. Everything was fresh and cooked perfectly. It was absolutely scrumptious. We finished with the chocolate fudge topped with vanilla gelato and honeycomb. It was our favorite meal and dining experience in NYC this weekend. We highly recommend!

Hands down the best hidden gem in North Jersey! I truly love this place and the staff. Never change a thing 😉

The food was great. My husband had the steak, and I had the shrimp prawns special. I would have appreciated that the description of the prawns included that they were heads on. Although the prawns were excellent, I’m not a fan of heads-on shrimp. In the least, you can ask the server to mention it.