Montclair​の居心地の良いお店

The food was outstanding. Service was excellent. It was quite loud however. It was hard to hear someone speak across the table. The views were lovely. Gorgeous decorations. Valet service was good as well.

We have been having our annual Christmas dinner at The Magic Lamp for many years and were greatly saddened last year when they had closed! To our skeptical delight they reopened under new ownership….one of the reasons we go there is we love the atmosphere, it’s magical and were apprehensive the new owners would have kept it even close to the same. WOW, we were beyond impressed!!! Not only did they keep the atmosphere but they GREATLY IMPROVED it all while keeping true to the what makes The Magic Lamp so special!! The food was amazing, the service impeccable, and they even had a singer (not too loud, just the right volume) by the wonderful indoor fire pit!! I would highly recommend going!! Anna was kind enough to show us the outside dinning area that is still in the works 🥰 to say it was FABULOUS would not do it justice!! Can’t wait to dine at The Magic Lamp again, soon!!! Thank you to the staff and new owners for keeping such an iconic restaurant experience going!! Bravo 👏

The food and service were both excellent. Donny room was mostly empty but the staff was very attentive. Food was fresh, hit and very good. We will be back!

Great steaks, especially the bone-in ribeye. The decor is fair to middling and utilitarian. They do have a lot of video screens.

It's always a pleasure having a meal here. The staff is very attentive and makes you feel welcomed at every opportunity. The food is amazing as always. We look forward to our next visit.