Lost Colony Tavern

Appetizers

Seasonal Hours. Mon-Thursday 11-8 Friday-Saturday 11-9 Sunday 11-4

• Baked Brie$12.00

  Creamy, imported Brie served with toasted almonds, crisp apples and toasted baguette

• Baked Crab Dip$13.00

  Savory au gratin dip topped with a generous portion of lump crab

• Basket of Fries$4.00

• Blue Cheesy Fries and Bacon$10.00

• Cheesy Fries and Bacon$8.00

• Chips and Salsa$5.00

  White corn tortilla chips served with our homemade salsa

• Crab Pretzel Au Gratin$13.00

  Large soft pretzel smothered in crab dip

• Hot Wings Marinated In Nags Head IPA$10.00

  Diablo, Teriyaki or Buffalo served with blue cheese or ranch

• Hummus$9.00

  Our famous version of the classic Middle Eastern bean dip. Drizzled with tahini and served with fried pita points and cucumbers

• Nachos$9.00

  White corn tortilla chips piled high with white cheddar, black olives, black beans, sour cream and salsa

  • Add Cajun Chicken or Pulled Pork$13.00

• Yellowfin Tuna Sashimi$12.00

  Rare, sushi-grade seared tuna with seaweed salad and Asian dipping sauce

Salads

• Blue Moon Waldorf$10.00

  Aged blue cheese, crisp apples and walnuts drizzled with balsamic vinaigrette

• Brie Salad$13.00

  Warm, creamy Brie served with ripe Granny Smith apples, toasted almonds and balsamic vinaigrette

• Caesar Salad$7.00

  Aged parmesan, homemade croutons, creamy Caesar dressing

• Cajun Chicken$5.00

• Greek Salad$9.00

  Crisp Romaine, grape tomatoes, black olives, Bermuda onions, cucumbers and feta

  • Add a Side of Hummus and Pita$11.00

• House Tossed Salad$5.00

  Field greens piled with fresh veggies

• Shrimp Salad$12.00

  Shrimp tossed with aioli, bay seasonings, celery and onion

• Soup and Salad

  Add a house tossed salad +$5 to Soup; Add a specialty salad (Caesar, Waldorf or Greek)+$7 to Soup

Salads Add-Ons

• Grilled Angus Ribeye$7.00

• Grilled Chicken$5.00

• Grilled Shrimp$6.00

• Lump Crab Cake$8.00

• Sushi-Grade Yellowfin Tuna$7.00

Soups

• Creamy Crab Bisque

  Soup served in a Bread Bowl +$3 to Soup

  • Cup$7.50
  • Bowl$9.50

Lunch Menu

Sandwiches

• Beer Brat$9.00

  Locally crafted bratwurst grilled with beer-braised peppers and onions

• Blue Cheese Mess$12.00

  Grilled tenderloin smothered with blue cheese and mushrooms

• Carolina Crab Cake

  Special blend of all-lump crab and bay seasonings topped with au gratin sauce

  • Market

• French Onion$12.00

  Grilled ribeye topped with swiss, beer-braised Bermuda onion, au jus

• Katelyn's Melt$10.00

  Cajun chicken with melted cheddar and bacon on a baguette

• North Carolina Pulled Pork BBQ$10.00

  Charon Stout BBQ sauce and coleslaw

• Oyster Po' Boy$12.00

  Fried local oysters with homemade pickles, remoulade, lettuce and tomato

• Rainforest$9.00

  The mother lode of veggies baked on a baguette with swiss and herb vinaigrette

• Roanoke Shrimp Melt$12.00

  Seasoned bay shrimp baked on a baguette with provolone and tomatoes

• Teriyaki Tuna$12.00

  Grilled sushi-grade tuna served with seaweed salad and pickled ginger

Burgers

• Angus Black and Cajun Blue$11.00

  Half-pound Angus burger topped with your choice of yummy toppings. All burgers served with fries

• Bacon Cheeseburger$10.00

  Half-pound Angus burger topped with your choice of yummy toppings. All burgers served with fries

• Cheese Burger$9.00

  Choice of Cheddar, Swiss or Provolone. Half-pound Angus burger topped with your choice of yummy toppings. All burgers served with fries

• Lump Crabmeat Au Gratin$14.00

  Half-pound Angus burger topped with your choice of yummy toppings. All burgers served with fries

• Mushroom and Swiss$11.00

  Half-pound Angus burger topped with your choice of yummy toppings. All burgers served with fries

• Tap House Burger$12.00

  Half-pound Angus burger topped with your choice of yummy toppings. All burgers served with fries

Specialties

• Beans and Rice$9.00

  Cuban-style beans and brown rice topped with cheddar, salsa and sour cream

• Fish and Chips$14.00

  Crispy house beer battered flounder served with fries

• Pasta Du Jour

  Artfully creative daily renditions

  • Market Price

• Quiche Du Jour

  Served with side salad

  • Market Price

• Shrimp and Grits$16.00

  A regional favorite! Shrimp sautéed with peppers, tomatoes, onions, black beans and Creole spices. Finished with andouille sausage, cream and polenta

Quesadillas & Enchiladas

• Black Bean Quesadilla$8.00

  All quesadillas are stuffed with black olives, tomatoes, onion, bell peppers and select cheeses. Served with tortilla chips, homemade salsa and sour cream

• Cajun Chicken Quesadilla$10.00

  All quesadillas are stuffed with black olives, tomatoes, onion, bell peppers and select cheeses. Served with tortilla chips, homemade salsa and sour cream

• Grilled Steak Quesadilla$12.00

  All quesadillas are stuffed with black olives, tomatoes, onion, bell peppers and select cheeses. Served with tortilla chips, homemade salsa and sour cream

• Shrimp and Crab Enchilada$16.00

  All quesadillas are stuffed with black olives, tomatoes, onion, bell peppers and select cheeses. Served with tortilla chips, homemade salsa and sour cream

• Shrimp Quesadilla$14.00

  All quesadillas are stuffed with black olives, tomatoes, onion, bell peppers and select cheeses. Served with tortilla chips, homemade salsa and sour cream

Wraps

• Bayou Wrap$10.00

  Cajun chicken rolled with tomatoes, bell peppers, onions, olives and cheddar

• Chicken Caesar Wrap$9.00

  Grilled chicken wrapped with tomatoes, romaine, parmesan, provolone and Caesar dressing

• Gatherer Wrap$9.00

  Spinach, hummus, guacamole, cukes, tomatoes, carrots, white cheddar, tahini (Served cold only)

• Gatherer Wrap$9.00

  Our famous shrimp salad rolled with lettuce, tomatoes and swiss. Served cold only

• Hunter Wrap$11.00

  Grilled Angus ribeye baked with onions, tomatoes, white cheddar and horseradish ale sauce

Dinner Menu

The Fried Stuff

• Chicken and Waffles$16.00

  With Imperial Mustard Syrup and fries

• Crab Cakes$26.00

  Served with fries and slaw

• House Beer Battered Fish and Chips$14.00

  Served with fries and slaw

• Local Oysters$20.00

  Served with fries and slaw

• Seafood Platter$26.00

  Fried Shrimp, Crab Cake, Flounder served with fries and slaw

• Shrimp$22.00

  Served fried with fries and slaw Make 'em Buffalo

The Daily Grill

• Angus Filet Mignon$25.00

  6 ounce cut served with artfully prepared sauces that change daily

• Chef's Choice Cut

  Always Angus, always grilled. Served with artfully prepared sauces that change daily

  • Market

• Fresh Catch of the Day$22.00

  Fresh, locally caught. 'Nough said

• Surf and Turf

  Chef's Choice Cut served with fresh, local seafood

  • Market

Specialties

• Local Scallops$26.00

  Pan-seared or blackened jumbo sea scallops

• Pasta Du Jour

  Artfully creative daily renditions

  • Market Price

• Quiche Du Jour

  Served with side salad

  • Market Price

• Shrimp and Crab Au Gratin$26.00

  Large, local shrimp topped with lump crab baked in au gratin sauce topped with provolone, parmesan and bread crumbs

• Shrimp and Grits$22.00

  A regional favorite! Shrimp sautéed with peppers, tomatoes, onions, black beans and Creole spices. Finished with andouille sausage, cream and polenta

Kids Menu

• Cheese Quesadilla$6.00

  Choice of applesauce or fries

• Chicken Tenders$8.00

  Choice of applesauce or fries

• Grilled Cheese on Baguette$6.00

  Choice of applesauce or fries

• Noodle Head$6.00

  Marinara or Butter Sauce

• Pita Pizza$6.00

  Choice of applesauce or fries